ElvisNews.com

Go to mainmenu / search box.

Home > Articles > DVD review

The Trouble With Girls (Case Number 4838)

By Judge Bill TreadwayAug 11, 2004
A verdict in case number 4838 (The Trouble With Girls) by Judge Bill Treadway from DVD Verdict.

The Charge

As American as the Fourth of July, apple pie, and Elvis!

Opening Statement

"Trouble" is right, dear readers. The Trouble with Girls is a colossal train wreck of a movie. The fact that it remains one of the lesser known, unseen Elvis Presley films is not a good omen. Despite elements that suggest a great film lurked within, the available evidence is sluggish and rather dull.

Facts of the Case

The year is 1927. Walter Hale (Elvis Presley, King Creole) is in charge of the Chautauqua, a nationwide traveling show. The film opens as the Chautauqua arrives in Radford Center, Iowa. The show consists of games, lectures, and sideshow attractions. And would it be an Elvis film without music?

A tug-of-war develops between Hale and the strong-minded feminist Charlene (Marlyn Mason) over the casting of the lead role in the Alice in Wonderland pageant. There's also a subplot featuring the roving eye of Harry Riley (Dabney Coleman, Modern Problems) who lusts over Mrs. Bix (Sheree North), his employee.

The Evidence

By the time our film was made, Elvis Presley was becoming tired of the standard musical comedies he had been churning out under the influence of his manager, Colonel Tom Parker. In 1969, no less than three atypical films were released as part of his attempt to break away from such fare: Charro!, a decent attempt at a straight Western; Change of Habit, which contained one of Presley's very best performances; and The Trouble with Girls, a strange bird of a movie. It is not a comedy, despite the efforts of MGM to promote it as such. It isn't a full-fledged musical, as Elvis only performs three songs, a low amount as far as he is concerned. It's too silly to succeed as drama and too historically inaccurate to pass as a period piece.

Before we go further with this review, let's get one thing straight: I am a big Elvis fan. I was pretty much one at birth, born to parents who loved the King like crazy. I grew up watching his films on television. Yet for the life of me, I never ever saw The Trouble with Girls in any form. When I saw this disc on the screener list, I requested it. As soon as it arrived, I popped the disc in the player and settled down for 99 minutes of good, clean fun.

I soon discovered the reason why The Trouble with Girls isn't better known and better regarded among the 33 films made by the King. The final cut is a disjointed mess. It appears as if the filmmakers shot enough film to make a three-hour film but were forced to a management-mandated running time of 99 minutes. How else to explain so many loose ends and unresolved threads? It has a promising start, with lively staging and stylish photography. The frenzied pace suggests a good time. After the opening credits, however, the film settles down to a monotonous snail's pace. We sit waiting for things to happen. When they do, the film quickly cuts to another story thread without resolving or explaining what happened before. Whole story threads are ignored, such as the aforementioned pageant.

The title is misleading to boot. It suggests a quirky battle-of-the-sexes comedy instead of giving us a hint of what the film is really about. Out of curiosity, I looked up the film on the Internet Movie Database and discovered a curious thing. The original title was The Chautauqua, which is a more accurate title than the one MGM slapped on. The film's G rating is as inaccurate as the title: This is a film that discusses very adult topics. The biggest howler is when Elvis talks about getting a girl into his bed, and that's just for starters. Yet, presumably because there is no nudity or foul language, the film receives a G rating.

There are some good things about the film that suggest it could have been better. Despite the brevity of his appearance and his "guest star" billing, Vincent Price perks things up considerably as Mr. Morality, one of the Chautauqua attractions. Watch his scenes and see a direction The Trouble with Girls could have taken. Joyce Van Patten is so hilarious as Hale's assistant that one wonders why they didn't make her the lead. John Carradine is a hoot as a Shakespearean actor; one wonders if most of his scenes were left on the cutting room floor for time. The few songs featured here are among the best ever in an Elvis film, and the final half-hour contains such energy, wit, and huge laughs that it makes the rest of the film look terrible by comparison.

The performances are difficult to judge due to the extreme unevenness of the screenplay. Despite his star billing, Elvis is given surprisingly little to do in the first forty minutes. His performance is quite good in the pieces provided, though: He has strong screen presence and makes a likable hero. Marlyn Mason, on the other hand, provides a performance that makes her the most irritating female lead in an Elvis picture since Donna Douglas in Frankie and Johnny. It is possible that the screenplay never fleshed out Charlene as a character, so Mason may not have had good material to work with. Still, it is an overacted, not to mention constipated, performance. Likewise, Dabney Coleman's villain isn't fleshed out enough to make us react strongly or care about what he does.

Warner Bros. presents The Trouble with Girls in 2.35:1 anamorphic widescreen. Despite the unevenness of the finished product, this is a handsomely shot film. The transfer accurately recreates the beautiful photography. Although there is some light grain and a smattering of specks here and there, the print used here appears to be very clean. Colors look sharp and lush, and edge enhancement is nil.

Audio is an above-average Dolby Digital 1.0 mono mix. Although Elvis doesn't sing as much as he usually does, the music remains an important element. The songs are mixed far higher than the dialogue, but this is a positive aspect rather than a debit. The dialogue is easy to hear, although considering how cheesy it is at times, one almost wishes for a muddier mix.

The sole extras provided are theatrical trailers for Spinout, Speedway, Double Trouble, and The Trouble with Girls. Watch the trailer for our film and see the predecessor of that marvel of modern studio promotion: the misleading trailer. All the trailers are presented in 2.35:1 anamorphic widescreen and look surprisingly great.

Closing Statement

As much of an Elvis fan as I am, I wasn't all that enraptured with The Trouble With Girls. I'm known as the guy who liked Speedway and Stay Away Joe, two of Elvis's most reviled films, so that has to say something. I'm only recommending this film to the most rabid Elvis fans on the planet. Casual viewers or those new to Elvis should check out Jailhouse Rock or Spinout instead. The Trouble with Girls is not the place to start.

Warner Bros. has made The Trouble with Girls affordable to purchase, but if you only have money for one Warner Bros. Elvis release, make it Spinout. Otherwise, go ahead and buy this disc. You're not going to hurt my feelings.

The Verdict

Warner has given The Trouble With Girls better treatment than it deserves. MGM is found guilty of false promotion and advertisement, taking an atypical film and advertising it as a typical Presley vehicle.
same day personal loan
guaranteed payday loans
one hour cash advance
Elvis Presley on: eBay, iTunes, Amazon, Sheetmusic

Reactions

dirklandwehr (profilecontact) wrote on Jul 19, 2005report abuse
While the movie itself isn't that good, Elvis looks just great here. The best scenes are the performances of "Clean Up Your Own Backyard" and "Swing Down, Sweet Chariot".
Joyce (profilecontact) wrote on Sep 12, 2004report abuse
The greatest, most important movies that were ever made were Elvis Presley movies. Five of those don't even have the outer form of "cheap entertainment for the masses" (whatever that may mean): Love Me Tender, Jailhouse Rock, King Creole, Flaming Star and Wild in the Country. His later movies (after Girls! Girls! Girls!) have a completely different character, and are much more difficult to interpret.
I think the way even people who call themselves 'fans' talk about these movies is extremely arrogant and, as a result of that, extremely stupid. It doesn't occur to them that when they don't like a movie (or any peace of art, for that matter), maybe they just don't understand it. They feel supported in their conceit by the obscene reviews these movies invariably got. Doesn't it occur to them that Presleys music got the same kind of reviews? Presley has always been hated by the so-called 'cultural elite'.
Nobody dares to call his music "howling and growling noises" anymore, as in the world of music Presley is now generally recognised as a genius. Unfortunately he has never got that kind of recognition as an actor, although, in his day, he was greatly admired by many directors, actors and scriptwriters.
Elvis Presley never played in a stupid movie. None of his movies was a 'vehicle'. His movie songs cannot be understood, when taken out of the context of the movie (Roy Orbison:"In his movies he is in character, and he sings in character").
Many of his later movies I find very depressing, but that is a different matter. I think that if you want to begin to understand these movies you have to see them all, in the order in which they were made.
E.L.V.I.S (profilecontact) wrote on Aug 29, 2004report abuse
Before bashing the film guys and gals you gotta remember that this were never gonna be 'hollywood classics'. They were a quick and easy way for producers and managers to drain every ounce of cash they could from elvis.
I think he knew this so never took the films that serious, just with a pintch of salt and had fun in the process. However each and every film has excellent soundtracks.
Trouble with girls isnt that bad really.Its fun, Its different and its enjoyable to watch.Againg the soundtrack for this film is very strong.Elvis' perforamnce is good but you can see its all just one big laugh for him, he may have gotten borded with the films but never got borded of the women in them :-)
GM (profilecontact) wrote on Aug 17, 2004report abuse
My copy of the new DVD arrived today....and guess what ? more DVD problems, on my copy the Dolby Digital Soundtrack is passable but the analogue track 9the one that comes through the TV) is missing!!! not a sound can be heard. I can live with this as I would always choose the Dolby track via my amp, but this is a terrible flaw.
Riozzi (profilecontact) wrote on Aug 16, 2004report abuse
it may not be his best film, but it's different, it's certainly not the worst(that distinction has to be harum scarum), but it does contain two of my alltime favourite elvis songs, 'swing down sweet chariot' and 'clean up your own backyard'
pacer1965 (profilecontact) wrote on Aug 13, 2004report abuse
I remember when i first watched The trouble with girls which was quite a while a go now. I was round my aunties house at the time and we both decided that we would watch tv. There we were watching this film not knowing it was an Elvis film. All of a sudden the king appeared boy were we surprised. I like this film its not a typical Elvis film i know you dont see the king much but when you do his acting is very good. I like this film more than clambake Paradise hawaiian style Easy come easy go and Harum scarum. The only film i dont like is Easy come easy go and that is an awful film.
LuckyJackson (profilecontact) wrote on Aug 13, 2004report abuse
I agree it's a strange movie but Elvis sure looks handsome and after all, he wasn't responsible for the scripts! He did the best he could and the twinkle in his eye suggests he wasn't taking it too seriously!
JerryNodak (profilecontact) wrote on Aug 12, 2004report abuse
I like this one because it's different. Doesn't have Elvis singing every 10 minutes and actually has a story. Whacky and unconventional as it might be. I didn't feel embarrassed for Elvis watching this. Unlike Harum Scarum for example. Has just a few songs that are used well.
Mike M (profilecontact) wrote on Aug 12, 2004report abuse
I agree with MV
MV (profilecontact) wrote on Aug 11, 2004report abuse
Come on its really not that bad.El looks great and at least its a bit different.He's not an ex-soldier/ navy/ airman/ racing car driver.Easily better than say Clambake, Harum,Easy Come, Tickle Me, Spinout, Kissin Cousins and Paradise. Along with Stay Away Joe one the better post '63 movies.
Neckywoudje (profilecontact) wrote on Aug 11, 2004report abuse
It's a terrible movie indeed! I bought the dvd yesterday, i'm a completist, but it goes about nothing. ECEG has more story than that. Elvis look better than in PHS, that's for sure. Awfull.
DannyB (profilecontact) wrote on Aug 11, 2004report abuse
Trouble W Girls is a terrible, terrible movie. I am embarrased on Elvis' behalf when watching it. Not because Elvis is bad in the movie, but the movie itself is terrible, terrible, terrible.. I had to watch the movie peace by peace to be able to get through it. The same goes for Easy Come Easy Go, the two worst movies Elvis ever did - next to Paradise Hawaiian Style. However, Trouble W Girls has some excellent songs! Clean up Your Own backyard and Almost, great songs.

DVD review: 10 most recent articles

17 reactions08/03/2010Elvis On Tour
4 reactions04/24/2009Hot Shots And Cool Clips 4
11 reactions01/07/2009Walk A Mile In My Shoes
18 reactions11/10/2008The 1972 New York Experience
 08/31/2008Fit For A King
1 reaction08/03/2008Preview Return To Tupelo
8 reactions07/13/2008Girl Happy

Recently Added Shop Items